
So my mother in law has requested The List. As she is the official shopper for most everyone on her side (herself, my father in law, the grandmothers…), each year she requests a Christmas list from us. My mother, queen of Christmas surprises, is horrified by this practice, but it saves my MIL a lot of stress by providing her with a whole bunch of stuff we want or need instead of leaving her to flounder blindly to figure it out. Obviously, we don’t get everything on it. That’s not the point. But in my years with this family, I have grown to appreciate this tradition, though historically I love surprises.
The thing is, we have a small house. And as an adult, I’d rather get the practical stuff that I want or need than some other surprise that I probably don’t and will only have to find a place to store (my office is full of junk my mother “surprised” me with that I would never have bought myself and have yet to find a way to get rid of. What’s on my list this year? Well for me, I really want another smaller crock pot and these particular shoes from Lands End, some sweaters or fleeces, and some books. Boring? Some might say so. But these are things I want and/or need and will have to buy myself. Given the state of our budget, it’s a great gift to me not to have to spend the money.
My mom has a hard time with this concept. She shops throughout the year and picks up stuff she thinks we’ll like. She asked me last month what my husband would like, and I pointed her to some shoes he loves (he’s already killed one pair). She said, “But they’re so ugly!” Mom falls into the classic gift giving blunder–she often won’t buy what someone truly wants because SHE doesn’t like it. Remember that when you’re shopping, y’all. Your friends and family members are not necessarily going to want the same thing you do.
And for heaven’s sake, don’t take it personally if the recipient returns it. My mother got me a truly hideous shirt last year in an effort to add something “hip” to my wardrobe. It looked like the 70s threw up. I returned it, bought 3 other plain button down shirts that I wear often. She had a fit that I didn’t like it and that I bought stuff exactly like what I already had. Well yeah, I like what I already had. I hated that shirt. I promise, it will mean more to the recipient if you think about what they want than what you like.
There are certainly merits to the Surprise! method of Christmas shopping. If you know your recipient really well and can truly give them something they’ll love–go for it. But don’t abhor the prospect of a list. It’s still a surprise to see what you got FROM the list. And even if it’s not…that’s not all bad either. I asked for a programmable crock pot last year. I knew I was getting it. And you know what? I absolutely LOVE the thing. I use it at least twice a week.
What does your family do? List or surprises?